Thursday, December 30, 2004

LokiTorrents—not low-key at all, really

Found on BoingBoing and Slashdot:

It seems that, rather than shut its doors like other high-profile BitTorrent sites like Suprnova.org, the BitTorrent site LokiTorrent.com is soliciting donations for a $30,000 legal defense fund to fight the MPAA's cease-and-desist orders against it. Apparently successfully, too.

To paraphrase Paul Simon in a song I wouldn't be suprised to find available in some collection or other via that very BitTorrent site, "Who do, who do they think they're fooling?" You have only to go to that site and look to see all the copyrighted games, music, and videos they're offering for download. This isn't an innocuous "save the bandwidth" torrent site for publicly available files, like the Slashdot Effect Victims 'torrent; this is a directory for out-and-out piracy. The "but gee, officer, we're just providing a directory" defense didn't fly with Napster, and I don't think it's going to fly here, either. The most they're going to do is set another anti-piracy legal precedent, just as the Napster case did.

It's happening just as some people in the content industry feared it would. Today's Internet culture doesn't just feel that piracy is okay, they actually feel a sense of entitlement to pirate. I've written about it before, how there are still people out there sharing files even though the RIAA is suing people left and right over it.

As I wrote then, I can't find it in myself to feel very sorry for these people. They knew what they were getting into when they started the game. If folks continue to share these files, they should be ready to pay the penalty when they get caught.

(Oh—and I have news for you BitTorrent users. You're nowhere near anonymous; they only have to access the tracker with a simple http query and they can get all the IPs of everyone connected to it. The MPAA is watching you, and will probably be suing you next.)

Thursday, December 23, 2004

Because a Mime is a Terrible Thing to Waste

You know, I really wish there were more people like this in American government.

I'm talking about former educator-turned-Bogotá (Colombia) Mayor Antanas Mockus, who instituted a series of amazing political and social reforms during his two mayoral terms. I encourage you to go and read the article, it's really amazing. When we Americans hear "Colombia," a lot of the time the first things that come to mind are drugs and corruption—and yet in this environment, this one man was able to make a great deal of difference in the way things were run. This is the sort of person Robin Williams gets typecast as in touching and inspirational based-on-real-life movies. You know, like Dead Poets Society and that one about the doctor? The man had some ideas that looked totally off the wall, like using mimes to cut down on traffic accidents—and yet, they worked amazingly well.

This puts me in mind of a common fantasy ideal about government reflected in a lot of movies in our culture. "Put a Common Man in a position of power and he'll make all the nasty bad corruption go away," they say. Mr. Smith Goes to Washington, Dave, even The Distinguished Gentleman imply that a pure heart (or at least only slightly tarnished, in the case of The Distinguished Gentleman) and good intentions can make everything okay again. They say that all the government's problems can be sorted out with the application of a little elbow grease and a little common sense. ("If I tried to run a business like this, I'd go bankrupt," Dave's accountant friend says when the erstwhile actor calls him in to consult on the national budget.)

Experts will tell you that this is purest fantasy, that government is a system of compromises and it takes an experienced, professional dealmaker to negotiate the best compromises that satisfy everybody and discomfit the smallest number of people. But every so often you see people like this, who imply with their actions and the results of those actions that there might just be a better way after all.

(Found via BoingBoing.)